Published on Sunday, 12 August 2012 11:57 Written by Michael Birnbaum
After the Sept. 11 attacks in the United States, security agencies around the world poured energy and funds into fighting Islamist terrorism, and Germany did so with special urgency, because several of the hijackers had lived in Hamburg. But the shift in this nation of 82 million people led to the neglect of other types of home-grown violence, critics now say, allowing a neo-Nazi scene to flourish with little attention paid to its dangers.
Although security services were keeping an eye on neo-Nazi groups, official assessments declared that the threat of right-wing terrorism was insignificant. But while resources were being concentrated on Islamist extremism, a small cell of neo-Nazis went undetected while it killed 10 people, nine of them with immigrant backgrounds, over seven years.
Police never suspected a right-wing connection — they found it only after the neo-Nazis dropped into their laps after a bungled bank robbery. Last week, Germany installed a new head of its equivalent to the FBI. He has sworn to overhaul the country’s intelligence services.
Keeping an eye on Islamist terrorism and knowing when to act on other threats can be a difficult balance in any country, with last week’s shootings at a Sikh temple in Wisconsin only the latest reminder. There, police say Wade Michael Page, with ties to “white power” groups, killed six people before turning his gun on himself.
In Germany, “our institutions didn’t have right-wing terrorism on their screens,” Sebastian Edathy, a member of Germany’s parliament who is leading an inquiry into the intelligence failures, said in an interview. “Society has focused over the last 10 years on the threat of Islamist extremism, but this is not the only extremist threat that we’re facing.”
The string of killings was already underway by Sept. 11, 2001, and they continued as Germany turned its attention away from neo-Nazis. A 2006 intelligence overhaul merged offices dealing with left-wing and right-wing extremism, in part to free resources for the fight against al-Qaeda and Islamist terrorism.
The focus had shifted so thoroughly by last year that a 473-page annual intelligence report by Germany’s Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution, roughly equivalent to the FBI, released not long before the neo-Nazi cell was discovered, said that “no structures of right-wing terrorism were detectable.”
‘No political will’
As for the killings, police said that they were likely part of an underworld dispute among Turkish crime gangs, and media dubbed them the doener murders after a popular Turkish kebab sandwich. The final victim was police officer Michele Kiesewetter, in April 2007, who police theorize may have been killed so that her attackers could secure another weapon.
The gang is also alleged to have committed more than a dozen bank robberies and the bombing of a hair salon in an immigrant neighborhood of Cologne. But until the dramatic discovery of weapons in the neo-Nazis’ burned-out home in southeastern Germany that linked them to the killings after a bungled bank robbery in November, police had not zeroed in on a racist motivation for the killings.
“There was no political will” to go after neo-Nazi groups, said Hajo Funke, a professor at the Free University of Berlin who is an expert on right-wing extremism. “This is one of the reasons the groups could go so widespread.”
Revelations this summer that German security service members had destroyed files related to the case the day after a neo-Nazi link became public in November only deepened suspicions about the security service’s role in pursuing the crimes. The German Interior Ministry has said that the shredding was a routine file purge unrelated to the news, but the head of the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution resigned as a result.
Neo-Nazis have found a home in the hard-bitten ex-Communist eastern portion of Germany, where jobs are scarce, anti-immigrant sentiments run high and Nazi-era attitudes toward minorities never fully disappeared. A neo-Nazi-linked political party, the National Democratic Party, holds seats in two state parliaments. Just this weekend, it held a rally in a town near the Polish border.
“The biggest success of the neo-Nazi movement is that eastern Germany is still white, because they’ve threatened people,” said Anetta Kahane, the head of the Amadeu Antonio Foundation, an organization that works to protect minority rights. “People with an immigrant background would never go there. And this is a third of the territory of a democratic country in the center of Europe.”
An intelligence review
Anti-neo-Nazi groups say that the attention given to the problem since November has helped sensitize security agencies to the violent potential of right-wing extremists, but controversy remains as to what to do to fight the problem.
The new head of Germany’s domestic intelligence agency, Hans-Georg Maassen, who was officially installed Friday, has resolved to improve communications between his federal office and the patchwork of 16 regional intelligence agencies. He promised a “comprehensive and self-critical” review of his agency’s work.
But for many critics, change at the top will do little to fend off the oversights that allowed the neo-Nazi group’s string of crimes to continue for so long. Nor are sheer resources the answer, they say. Instead, all levels of the security services, and society, need to be more conscious about the threat of racism-driven crime.
“It is very essential and crucial to keep in mind that you don’t have only one kind of extremism, and you can’t neglect one part of it to focus on another,” said Edathy, the member of parliament. “You have to deal with the threat appropriate to its relevance.”
Credit: Washington Post